What is the Brown Rule? What is the Time Rule Formula?
Background on the Brown Rule & the Time Rule Formula
A California court case from 1976 established that non-vested retirement benefits were community property, subject to division upon dissolution of marriage. This case was In Re Marriage of Brown (1976) 15 Cal. 3rd 838. After the Brown case, courts started utilizing a formula to divide retirement benefits – over time, this formula became known as the Time Rule Formula or the Brown Rule. The court in a dissolution of marriage action is authorized to divide community property equally, and must utilize a formula that will accomplish an equal division.
What is the Time Rule Formula?
When the Time Rule Formula is utilized, the community property interest in retirement benefits is determined by a fraction whose numerator is the employee’s length of service from the date of marriage through the date of separation, and whose denominator is the employee’s total length of service at retirement.
As a simplified example, if a spouse was married for 10 years during which time she worked for the same employer and accrued retirement benefits, but then retired after 20 total years of service with said employer, the community property interest in the retirement benefits would be 10/20 or 50%. The remaining 50% would be the employee’s separate property. Further, the community interest is divided equally between the parties, so the non-employee spouse would receive 25% of the total retirement benefits, and the employee spouse would receive 75% of the total retirement benefits.
Are the Brown Rule and Time Rule Formula Really the Same Thing?
Although many divorce attorneys use the terms “Brown Rule” and “Time Rule Formula” interchangeably, they are not actually the same thing. A 2007 case, In Re Marriage of Gray, established that the term “Brown Formula” was not always accepted as having the same meaning as the “Time Rule.” Instead, the court held that the basic principles from the Brown case were that i) nonvested pension rights are community property subject to division and ii) that the court may achieve division either by cashing out the nonemployee spouse through the reduction of the rights to the present value or by retaining jurisdiction to achieve the division later as the pension benefits accrue and are subject to payment. The Gray court determined that the Brown case, on its face, did not actually establish or promote what came to be known as the Time Rule formula, or any other specific formula, for dividing pensions in divorce. If it is the parties’ intention to utilize the formula described above, the Martial Settlement Agreement should state that the retirement benefits will be divided pursuant to the “Time Rule” not the “Brown formula.”
When Should the Time Rule Formula be Used?
The Time Rule Formula should only be used for defined benefit plans where the amount of retirement benefits is substantially related to the number of years of service. If the amount of benefits is related to another factor, a different formula may be needed. It should also be noted that the Time Rule is inappropriate for defined contribution plans, like 401(k) plans, because the benefits paid out at retirement are directly related to the contributions made and are not substantially related to the number of years of service. Further, the contributions made during the marriage are likely not equal to the contributions made before or after marriage.
Questions About Your California QDRO or the Time Rule or Brown Formula?
If you have questions about the division of retirement benefits in your divorce, or if you would like to get started on your QDRO today, please call QDRO Helper at 619-786-QDRO (619-786-7376) or click here to request a new client package.
DISCLAIMER: Any legal information on this blog has been prepared by QDRO Helper for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice. The material posted on this website is not intended to create, and receipt of it does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship, and readers should not act upon it without seeking professional counsel. Note also that sending an e-mail to QDRO Helper does not create an attorney-client relationship, and none will be formed unless there is an express agreement between the firm and the individual. We strongly advise against sending confidential or privileged information to QDRO Helper until you can establish such a relationship.